Search
  • JCLJ Admin

THE FARM ACT – A SHIFT TOWARDS CAPITALISM

Three bills were passed by the parliament in the month of September which invoked widespread criticism across the country. India is land of farmers, the agricultural industry provides employment to over 60% of the population. This sector alone contributes nearly about 17% of the GDP.

Bill’s introduced

  1. The Farmer Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Ordinance 2020.

  2. The Farmer (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance Farm Service Ordinance 2020.

  3. The Essential Commodities ( Amendment ) Ordinance 2020.

These ordinances were introduced in Lok Sabha by Narendra Singh Tomar(Ministry of Agriculture and Family Welfare). The ordinances were enacted by Lok Sabha on 17th September 2020 and by Rajya Sabha on 20th September 2020. It received the president’s assent on 27th September 2020.


The Farmer Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act 2020

This act promotes inter-state and intra-state trade of farmers produce beyond the perimeter of Agricultural Produce Market Committee i.e. now farmers can sell their produce to private owners or any other person (retailers, private companies, online market etc.). This act also bars the state to levy any tax or cess on the produce.

Pros

By increasing the perimeter of trade the act has enabled the farmers to trade their produce in the open market as earlier they were only trading with AMCP. And since the state cannot levy any taxes it will be helpful to farmers.

Cons

Now that the farmers can sell their produce in the open market they are more prone to fraud and corruption by the private buyers.

The state was able to generate a certain amount of income by levying taxes on the purchase or export of product as the amount was invested in storing and exporting of the product by the state.


The Farmer (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance Farm Service Act2020.

This act promotes contract farming i.e. trade between the farmers and the purchaser will be secure with a contract between them which will be binding on the buyers.

Pros

Contract farming will ensure a fixed amount of income for the products and this will attract private investors.

Cons

Majority of farmers are uneducated they don’t know the intricacies of the contract they don’t have enough funds to consult a lawyer they can easily be fooled by private buyers and easily be exploited.


The Essential Commodities (Amendment)Act 2020

This act removes commodities like cereal, pulse, oilseeds, onion, edible oils and potatoes from the list of essential commodities. It also removed the ban on stockpiling except for certain food products that can be regulated only under extraordinary circumstances i.e. war, famine and natural calamity.

Pros

It will promote economic growth and will attract private sector and increase the flow of foreign direct investment in the agricultural sector.

Cons

Stockpiling will lead to price fluctuation and low price for farmers after harvest. It will promote the black market business.


The opinion of those opposing it

Not a balanced act- The act is more in favour of private buyers(capitalist).

Weak structure of minimum selling price- procurement is not done for all the crops but only for some crops. As private investment may vary and so will be the MSP and it is also not fixed.

Middlemen influence will remain same - In earlier structure, there was the middleman between the farmers and the retailers which promoted corruption now also there will be the middle man to guide farmers and investors.

Government Investment- Agricultural sector is the main pillar of the Indian economy giving it in the hand of private investors and companies will prove to be fatal. Government is the major stakeholder can shield farmers from getting exploited and also guarantee legal rights to farmers but the same will not be in case of private buyers.

Agricultural Product Market Committee needs to be reformed- APMC needs to be reformed but not to be replaced.

Affect Employment- Removal of APMC and government control will affect employment as the major working-class of the village is employed in these APMC and it will severely affect daily wages workers as private sectors will focus on employing educated masses.


The author of this post is Saman Rahman(a student at Faculty of Law, University of Lucknow)

The views expressed in this article belong to the author/s and do not necessarily reflect those of the JCLJBlog. We welcome comments and contributions to this blog – please comment below.


#farms #farmers

20 views0 comments

Copyright © 2020 Juris Club Law Journal | All rights reserved           Designed by Shishir Yadav

  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
Visitors